Sindarin Grammar P14: Liquid Mutation

Sindarin Grammar P14: Liquid Mutation

Liquid mutation results from a preceding liquid r, l. This is a rather speculative mutation, based only a couple of examples and what we know about Sindarin’s phonetic history. The only examples of liquid mutation appear in a couple of phrases from a document referred to as the Túrin Wrapper (VT50/5):

In both phrases, Tolkien first wrote unmutated forms pent and cem before deleting them and replacing them with mutated phent and chem. These changes are consistent with the historical sound changes whereby voiceless stops become voiceless spirants after liquids and voiced stops became voiced spirants after liquids. Thus the main phonological result of liquid mutation is to turn stops into spirants. In the case of g, this spirant would be ultimately be lost as it was in soft mutation. Probably initial h would “mutate” to ch because the sound change whereby initial [x-] became [h-] was inhibited, and likewise other voiceless sounds (hw, lh, rh) would be voiced.

Outside of the Turin’s wrapper, however, there is considerable evidence that liquid mutation was not a feature of modern Sindarin, and that the spirantalization of stops after liquids was no longer an active sound change in the language. In the King’s Letter there are a couple of uses of the conjugation ar “and” where no liquid mutation occurs (SD/128):

This sound change is seen in some ancient names like Barthan “World-artificer” = bâr + tân, Erchamion “One-handed” = er + cam, Belthil “Divine Radiance” = bal + til. But there are a number of later compounds that show soft mutation instead, such as:

  • calardan “lampwright” = calar + tan (PE17/96; RC/523).
  • ithildin “moon-star” = Ithil + tin (LotR/317; PE17/66).
  • Tegilbor “Calligrapher, *Pen-fist” = tegil + paur (PM/318).
  • Tharbad “Crossway” = thar + pad (LotR/274; PE17/34).

Also, consider the following quote from the Quendi and Eldar essay discussing the plurals of compounds:

As a pronoun, usually enclitic, the form pen, mutated ben, survived. A few compounds survived, such as rochben “rider” (m. or f.), orodben “a mountaineer” or “one living in the mountains”, arphen “a noble”. Their plurals were made by i-affection, originally carried through the word: as rœchbin, œrydbin, erphin, but the normal form of the first element was often restored when the nature of the composition remained evident: as rochbin, but always erphin.

This quote indicates that i-affection of plurals only applies to the second element of recognized compounds (rochbenrochbin) but i-affection applies to the entire word when the compound was no longer recognized (arphenerphin). If liquid mutation remained an active sound change in Sindarin, it would be hard to explain how arphen was not recognized as a compound.

Nevertheless, liquid mutation has remained a popular feature of Neo-Sindarin ever since it was first proposed by David Salo in his book, A Gateway to Sindarin (GS/78-79). Most Neo-Sindarin mutation charts include it, and there is some evidence (Turin’s Wrapper) that Tolkien at least considered it. It is also possible that it is an archaic mutation that has fallen out of use once the relevant sound changes ceased to be active in Sindarin, possibly as early as the arrival of the Noldor in Beleriand in the First Age, but almost certainly by the Second and Third Ages.

Summary: I would rate liquid mutation as a “very optional” mutation for purpose of Neo-Sindarin, since the evidence that Tolkien used it is limited to a single source (the Túrin Wrapper) and there is considerable evidence against it elsewhere. If you do use it, here is a summary its probable effects:

  • Initial voiceless stops (p, t, c) become voiceless spirants (ph, th, ch).
  • Initial voiced stops (b, d, g) become voiced spirants (v, dh) or are lost: g.
  • Initial nasalized voiced stops ([m]b, [n]d, [n]g) do not mutate (remain b, d, g).
  • Voiceless sounds (hw, lh, rh) are voiced to ’w, ’l, ’r.
  • h becomes ch.

The l, r in the preceding preposition is not modified in any way.

Comments

Submitted by Lokyt Thu, 06/18/2020 - 23:44

Il in il chem is a quantifier, but one that precedes its complement (they usually follow it in S.).
Now, another such one is er. And since it also happens to end in a liquid, I'd say it triggers the mutation too (in the version of S. where the mutation exists at all).

Submitted by Lokyt Sat, 06/27/2020 - 01:07

It might be worth to add what happens to the primitive mb-, nd-, ng-.
Theoretically e.g. -r·nd- should simply shrink to -r·d-. And funnily enough, this is exactly what Tolkien gives in what seems to be the earliest exemplification of the liquid mutation (or rather an absence thereof) in PE 11/9.